In an Online World, Identifying Hidden Competitors is Critical

courses blue key

February 8, 2021

There is a good chance that you are losing potential students right from your own backyard. In the post-COVID world, online education is growing and the competition for student demand is intense.  Students in your markets may be going right out of your own proverbial backyard, and if you aren’t looking at the right data, you may not even know it, let alone correct for it. Accurate insights are critical for making the most efficient program decisions and investing in drawing your students closer to home.

When Evaluating Online Attendance, Traditional Data is Misleading

Traditional data sources such as IPEDS are out of date, and they do not show the true picture of competition in the online space.  There is better data out there, if you know where to find it and how to bring it all together.  You can’t guess at this process to be effective; the right tools will guide you to address student demand, build efficiency and grow your programs.

The Problem with IPEDS Reports and Online Competition

Student demand: Consider the most recent IPEDS report for Spring 2018. Students’ program choices were made years before 2018, when they chose their major.  As a result, IPEDS shows what students wanted in the past.  The world and student demand change too quickly to rely on data that reflects student interest from up to five years prior.

Online competition: Here is where IPEDS data falls short.  Colleges report most online completions to their headquarters’ market, not the home market of their students.  In headquarters markets, IPEDS competition is overstated.  Everywhere else, competition nearly disappears.  For example, the University of Phoenix reports its 30,000 online completions in Phoenix (see map), even though its students are scattered across the country.

IPED Completions University of Phoenix

How Gray DI Fixed the Online Competition Reporting Problem

Fixing the problem: Gray identified and addressed the online competition reporting problem head on, offering the most current and accurate data for informed analysis and decision making.

To locate online students in the states in which they are actually enrolled, Gray examines the most recent data from NC-SARA ( National Council for State Authorization Reciprocity Agreements) filings.  We then combine this with two additional current proprietary sources: institutional completions by program and search data at the county level. This results in current and accurate results, allowing us to show students—and your online competition—in the correct markets. The difference between IPEDS reporting and Gray reporting speaks for itself. As you can see from the map, our example, the University of Phoenix shows its true competitive reach, far outside of just Arizona alone. Truly revealing.  Furthermore, the data also shows in which cities this competition is strongest.

University of Phoenix completions by home market

Keeping track of who is really in your markets and what programs they offer can help ensure that online revenue stays at home, too.

Source: Gray DI

Gray Associates

Gray Associates, Inc. provides the best available data, software, and facilitated processes to help higher education institutions make high-stakes decisions regarding academic programs, pricing, and locations.

About Gray DI

Gray DI provides data, software and facilitated processes that power higher-education decisions. Our data and AI insights inform program choices, optimize finances, and fuel growth in a challenging market – one data-informed decision at a time.

Related Posts
Subscribe to Our Blog

Don’t miss our latest research and insights

Related Posts

Gray Insights

The AI Tutor: A Human-Centered Approach

AI tutors can be transformative—but only when built the right way. Curious what that actually takes? From avoiding AI “hallucinations” to protecting professors’ content and making sure students get real support (not shortcuts), this deep dive breaks down the must-haves for building AI that truly belongs in the classroom.

Read More
Gray Insights

Mars: The Next Giant Leap for Humankind

Mars is no longer just the stuff of science fiction—it’s emerging as the next grand challenge for humanity, demanding expertise far beyond rocket science. From sustainable life-support systems to interplanetary law and supply chain logistics, preparing for a future on the Red Planet calls for a truly multidisciplinary approach. With universities already launching innovative programs in space exploration, planetary science, and even Martian community simulations, the groundwork for our next giant leap is already underway.

Read More
Gray Insights

Beyond the RCM Budget: Seeing the Real Story of Your University’s Finances

Behind every college budget lies a deeper story—one that traditional reports often miss. With tools like Gray DI’s Program Economics, academic leaders can move beyond broad revenue and expense figures to uncover what’s really driving costs, margins, and strategic opportunities at the course and program level. From identifying which courses quietly subsidize others to making precise, data-informed adjustments, this level of insight turns financial management into a powerful tool for shaping the future of higher education.

Read More